Value Your Vote - Interim Report 2012

Overall Party Mark

Key

Consistent with Family First position
Contrary to Family First position
No Vote
Street prostitutionGambling harmBail lawsChild supportEaster TradingPaid parental leaveGay marriageDrinking age
Act
John Banks
50%
Green
Steffan Browning
38%
David Clendon
38%
Catherine Delahunty
38%
Julie Anne Genter
38%
Dr Kennedy Graham
50%
Kevin Hague
38%
Gareth Hughes
38%
Jan Logie
38%
Mojo Mathers
38%
Russel Norman
38%
Denise Roche
38%
Eugenie Sage
38%
Metiria Turei
38%
Holly Walker
38%
Labour
Jacinda Ardern
75%
Charles Chauvel
75%
David Clark
88%
Clayton Cosgrove
75%
David Cunliffe
75%
Clare Curran
63%
Lianne Dalziel
75%
Ruth Dyson
63%
Kris Faafoi
75%
Darien Fenton
75%
Phil Goff
88%
Chris Hipkins
75%
Parekura Horomia
63%
Raymond Huo
75%
Shane Jones
63%
Annette King
88%
Iain Lees-Galloway
75%
Andrew Little
88%
Moana Mackey
75%
Nanaia Mahuta
75%
Trevor Mallard
75%
Sue Moroney
88%
Damien O'Connor
100%
David Parker
75%
Rajen Prasad
63%
Grant Robertson
75%
Ross Robertson
88%
David Shearer
75%
Su'a William Sio
100%
Maryan Street
88%
Rino Tirikatene
75%
Phil Twyford
75%
Louisa Wall
75%
Megan Woods
75%
Mana
Hone Harawira
25%
Maori
Te Ururoa Flavell
50%
Pita Sharples
75%
Tariana Turia
75%
National
Amy Adams
63%
Shane Ardern
75%
Chris Auchinvole
63%
Kanwaljit Singh Bakshi
75%
Maggie Barry
50%
David Bennett
63%
Paula Bennett
50%
Jackie Blue
50%
Chester Borrows
88%
Simon Bridges
75%
Gerry Brownlee
50%
Dr Cam Calder
63%
David Carter
38%
Jonathan Coleman
63%
Judith Collins
63%
Jacqui Dean
50%
Bill English
50%
Christopher Finlayson
63%
Craig Foss
50%
Paul Goldsmith
50%
Jo Goodhew
63%
Tim Groser
38%
Nathan Guy
63%
John Hayes
75%
Phil Heatley
75%
Tau Henare
50%
Paul Hutchison
63%
Steven Joyce
38%
Nikki Kaye
50%
John Key
38%
Colin King
63%
Melissa Lee
63%
Peseta Sam Lotu-Iiga
88%
Tim Macindoe
88%
Todd McClay
75%
Murray McCully
38%
Ian McKelvie
50%
Mark Mitchell
63%
Alfred Ngaro
75%
Simon O'Connor
63%
Hekia Parata
63%
Jami-Lee Ross
50%
Eric Roy
75%
Tony Ryall
75%
Mike Sabin
75%
Katrina Shanks
75%
Scott Simpson
63%
Lockwood Smith
50%
Nick Smith
63%
Lindsay Tisch
50%
Annette Tolley
63%
Chris Tremain
63%
Louise Upston
75%
Nicky Wagner
50%
Kate Wilkinson
38%
Maurice Williamson
38%
Michael Woodhouse
75%
Jian Yang
63%
Jonathan Young
88%
NZ First
Brendan Horan
* now an Independent MP since these votes
88%
Asenati Lole-Taylor
88%
Tracey Martin
88%
Denis O'Rourke
88%
Winston Peters
88%
Richard Prosser
88%
Barbara Stewart
88%
Andrew Williams
88%
United Future
Peter Dunne
63%

The Issues

Manukau City Council (Regulation of Prostitution in Specified Places) Bill
February 2012

Violence, turf wars and streets littered with syringes and used condoms at Hunters Corner and Manurewa led the former Manukau City Council to have a bill introduced to Parliament. But with the advent of the Super City, the Regulation of Prostitution in Specific Places Bill has been amended to reflect the new governance structure, which means that the Auckland Council could pass bylaws to outlaw street prostitution anywhere in the city. Under the bill, the council must specify where street prostitution is outlawed. It cannot apply a blanket ban. The bill would enable prostitutes to be moved out of residential areas. The Greens labelled the bill “repugnant’! Although Labour supported this bill being referred to a select committee, almost 2/3’rds of the MP’s had previously voted against the ‘Manukau City’ version in 2010.

Source: NZ Herald http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=10702523

Dominion Post http://www.stuff.co.nz/auckland/local-news/manukau-courier/6529662/Street-prostitution-move

Read more info http://familyfirst.org.nz/issues/ban-on-street-prostitution/

FAMILY FIRST POSITION: SUPPORT
Gambling (Gambling Harm Reduction) Amendment Bill
May 2012

The gambling bill gives councils and the public power to cut the number of poker machines in their area and ensure that gambling proceeds are fed back into the immediate community. The Government has agreed to support this bill through to select committee as part of the Relationship Accord with the Maori Party. The bill:

  • Gives councils power to eliminate or reduce pokies at a venue if the public feels they are harmful.
  • Ensures 80 per cent of gambling proceeds return to the community where the money was lost.
  • Phases out the corporate societies which distribute pokie earnings, and replaces them with transparent, local committees.
  • Insists that venues introduce gambler tracking systems which measure losses, and pre-commit cards which allow players to preset the time and money they gamble.
  • Removes special status of the racing industry as a recipient for the purpose of racing stakes.

Source: NZ Herald http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=10804202

Read more info http://familyfirst.org.nz/issues/gambling-harm/

FAMILY FIRST POSITION: SUPPORT
Bail Amendment Bill 2012
May 2012

Ministry of Justice figures on the number of serious crimes committed while on bail shows the urgent need for improve public safety. Family First supports the purposes of the Bill to improve public safety, and to ensure that those accused of serious offences will find it more difficult – although not impossible – to get bail. We support the changes which reverse the burden of proof for those charged with the worst offences and with the highest risk of reoffending while on bail. We agree that public safety should be the court’s primary consideration. We support the extension to the list of offences that qualify a defendant to be subject to a reverse burden of proof when they have a similar previous conviction We agree that the presumption in favour of bail for young (17-19 year old) defendants who have previously been in prison should be removed. We also support new powers for the police to deal with bail breaches by young people (<17). Names such as Christie Marceau, Natasha Hayden, Aaliyah Morrissey and Vanessa Pickering highlight the need for improved bail laws to protect families. Bail is a privilege, not a right. And the rights of the public to protection from repeat and high risk offenders should take precedence.

Read more info http://familyfirst.org.nz/issues/bail-laws/

FAMILY FIRST POSITION: SUPPORT
Child Support Amendment Bill 2011
May 2012

The bill amends the child support scheme which was introduced in 1992 and which helps to provide financial support for over 210,000 children, by making provision for:

  • a new child support calculation formula;
  • Secondary changes to update the child support scheme more generally;
  • amendments to the payment, penalty, and debt rules for child support.

A number of recommendations made by Family First in its submission have been adopted, including taking the income of both parents into account rather than just the paying parent’s income; recognising shared care of a child at lower levels than the current 40% of nights test; and automatic deduction of child support payments from wages. For the sake of the children in terms of contact and material needs, and the financial pressures on sole parents, we must ensure that the system is fair to both parents and places the same obligation, responsibility, and role on each parent. Many parents are being alienated from their children – even when they may oppose the separation – and are then financially liable in an unfair way. The current regime has been too inflexible and has led to unjust results. The latest proposals will go some way to addressing that unfairness. There is obviously an issue with parents going overseas and avoiding their responsibilities – and children are the ultimate losers in this.

Read more info http://familyfirst.org.nz/issues/child-support

FAMILY FIRST POSITION: SUPPORT
Shop Trading Act Repeal (Waitaki Easter Trading) Amendment Bill
June 2012

According to New Zealand law, most shops must close on Good Friday, Easter Sunday, Christmas Day and the morning of ANZAC Day. Politicians are constantly trying to liberalise the laws in their local areas – the latest attempt being this one by National MP Jacqui Dean in her Waitaki electorate. There have been two previous attempts to free up Easter trading in Rotorua. Poll after poll has shown that both parents and children want to spend more time together doing family things like picnics and holidays together. However, this is becoming increasingly difficult as the retail industry is required to work almost every day of the year, and shoppers focus on the holiday specials. Public holidays are traditions. They create rituals for families, not based on shopping but on celebrating together, reconnecting, and making memories. Many countries have public holidays with shops closed, and tourists simply plan around it, accepting it as part of the local culture and identity. The politicians should give the workers a break and leave the Christmas and Easter trading laws alone.

Read more info http://familyfirst.org.nz/2010/04/new-zealanders-not-yet-ready-for-a-change-to-easter-trading-hours/

http://familyfirst.org.nz/2009/12/rejection-of-easter-trading-good-for-family-life/

FAMILY FIRST POSITION: OPPOSE
Parental Leave and Employment Protection (Six Months’ Paid Leave) Amendment Bill
July 2012

Successive governments have undervalued families and families are being penalised for having children. The political and policy focus has been on the needs of the economy, rather than on the welfare of children and the vital role of parents. In reality, this policy would represent about 0.2% of the total government spending, yet research shows that the role of mothers and the early bonding between mums and babies is vital for healthy child development. Ironically, the spending on early childhood education has almost tripled in the past ten years – yet there was no suggestion of a veto by the government then, as there has been on this bill. A 2008 report by UNICEF rated New Zealand 23rd out of 25 countries for effective paid parental leave. Kiwi parents get 14 weeks paid parental leave while the average in the rest of the developed world is approaching one year. In 2009, the Families Commission called for an extension of paid parental leave to at least 12 months. A recent Department of Labour evaluation of paid parent leave showed that only ¼ of mothers thought the paid parental leave was long enough, and up to 75% said ideally they would take a year off. Yet the average time at which mothers return to work is when their baby is six months old. Only 14 weeks of that is paid. ‘Financial pressure’ was cited as a key reason for returning to work earlier than desired. The role of parents during the crucial early years of a child should be acknowledged.

Read more info http://familyfirst.org.nz/issues/paid-parental-leave/

FAMILY FIRST POSITION: SUPPORT
Marriage (Definition of Marriage) Amendment Bill
August 2012

The same-sex marriage bill was introduced by Labour MP Louisa Wall to “provide the same rights, responsibilities and privileges of marriage to two people who choose this form of expression of their relationship”. But equality does not mean we must redefine marriage. Many people in the homosexual community do not agree with same-sex marriage. Like us, they simply hold a particular view on an important social issue. This argument has nothing to do with hate or fear, as is wrongly charged by supporters of the bill, and everything to do with history, culture and tradition. For many, marriage is more than just a legal agreement or social contract. We must consider the rights of people who have deliberately chosen marriage because of its cultural, religious and historical meaning. By changing its meaning, we would be trampling on the rights of a significant proportion of New Zealanders. It is perfectly possible to support traditional marriage, while also recognising and respecting the rights of others. There is absolutely no need to redefine marriage to provide legal recognition and protection for committed same-sex relationships. In 2004, the government introduced Civil Unions and changed over 150 pieces of legislation to achieve this very thing. Adults have a right to form meaningful relationships – they just don’t have a right to redefine marriage.

Read more info http://www.protectmarriage.org.nz/

FAMILY FIRST POSITION: OPPOSE
Alcohol Reform Bill (Increase Drinking Age)
August 2012

Health boards, health professionals, police, family groups, addiction experts, the Prime Minister’s chief science adviser, leading scientists, and the general public – including young people – were all shouting to politicians to raise the drinking age to 20 in order to protect young people and to save lives. The split-age proposal would have been confusing, sending a mixed message, and was not supported by frontline workers who were mopping up the mess of alcohol abuse on a regular basis. Alcohol policies and decisions about a legal drinking age should be firmly based on the health and well-being of New Zealand’s young people. New medical evidence on accident probability, disease and brain development, along with the Child and Youth Mortality Review, and the recommendations of the Prime Minister’s chief science adviser, made it absolutely clear that delaying the age at which teenagers and young people have easy access to alcohol would reduce the level of damage they and society suffer at the moment as well as contributing to their future health and well-being. Raising the drinking age was not intended to be a cure-all solution to alcohol abuse, but it was intended to challenge a liberal environment in which alcohol is easily accessible and too often abused, especially by young people. Unfortunately the politicians ‘dropped the ball’ yet again on this issue.

Read more info http://familyfirst.org.nz/issues/alcohol-law-reform/

FAMILY FIRST POSITION: SUPPORT

AUTHORISED BY BOB MCCOSKRIE, 652 GT SOUTH RD, MANUKAU CITY 2241

NOTE: The information presented on this website is based on the actual voting record in 2012 on a number of family related issues. It is not intended to endorse any particular candidate or party, and voters are encouraged to make informed decisions on the candidates’ and parties’ policies across many issues. This website offers a limited but nevertheless important perspective to each candidate and party in matters important to families.

Every attempt has been made to accurately represent the voting record of MP’s. We welcome any documented corrections.

built for Family First by <incode>